via City of Miami v. Miami Association of Firefighters, Local 587, 744 So. 2d 555 (October 29, 1999):
In 1999 the City of Miami scheduled an election to ask voters to approve an amendment to the City Charter. A group that included the Miami firefighters union, the Fraternal Order of Police, AFSCME Local 1907, several residents and the Coconut Grove Civic Club asked the circuit court to stop it, and the court enjoined the election.
The circuit court found the proposal defective because it combined two subjects: restructuring the City government and an early election for mayor. It relied on the single-subject requirement in Florida Statute §166.041(2), which applies to municipal ordinances and resolutions.
What the appeals court decided
The Third District Court of Appeal reversed and let the election go forward. It held that the statute does not govern charter amendments for cities in Miami-Dade County, because the Miami-Dade Home Rule Amendment makes the county charter the exclusive method for amending a city charter, and the county charter has no single-subject requirement. The court did not decide the argument that an early strong-mayor election was invalid because the sitting mayor had a right to finish his term, since the mayor was not a party to the case. Because of the time constraints, it barred motions for rehearing.
Luis Fernandez’s role
The opinion lists Luis Fernandez among the lawyers for the appellees (the group that challenged the election), with Kendall Coffey, Benedict P. Kuehne, W. Tucker Gibbs and others.
Source
City of Miami v. Miami Association of Firefighters, Local 587, 744 So. 2d 555 (Fla. 3d DCA 1999)
Anna Fernandez, Esq., Legal Lotus, P.A., Coral Gables, Florida, is the designated inventory attorney for the practice of Luis Fernandez, P.A.
One thought on “The 1999 Miami Charter Election Case”